Why Performance Brands Are Ditching Vanity Metrics in 2025
- Team Adtitude Media
- Jun 4, 2025
- 2 min read
Vanity metrics are out. Value metrics are in. In 2025, performance-driven brands are rethinking how they measure success. Impressions, likes, and follower counts may look impressive in reports, but they’re losing favour among smart marketers who are now prioritizing metrics that move the revenue needle.
Let’s explore why this shift is happening, what metrics are replacing vanity ones, and how forward-thinking brands are transforming their growth strategies.
What Are Vanity Metrics — and Why They’re Misleading
Vanity metrics are surface-level numbers that don’t necessarily correlate with business outcomes. They include:
Social media likes and followers
Ad impressions
Video views (without action)
Website traffic without engagement
Email open rates (without clicks or conversions)
These numbers may make a campaign look successful, but they don’t prove impact on sales, customer retention, or ROI.
The 2025 Wake-Up Call: Why the Shift Is Happening Now
Several macro shifts are pushing performance brands to evolve their metrics game:
Platform algorithm changes
Meta, Google, and TikTok are optimizing for deeper engagement and conversion, not just reach. Brands that focus only on impressions are missing the full picture.
Budget accountability in a tight economy
CMOs are under pressure to demonstrate a return on investment (ROI). Every dollar spent needs to show a return, not just attention.
Rise of first-party data
As cookie deprecation continues, brands are investing in owned data and real user behaviour, moving from guesswork to measurable value.
AI + automation in media buying
With automated bidding and creative optimization, marketers can’t afford to obsess over inputs (like reach). The focus is now on outputs — specifically conversions, customer acquisition cost (CAC), and retention.
The Metrics That Matter in 2025
Here’s what high-performance brands are tracking now instead:
Old Metric (Vanity) | New Metric (Performance) |
Likes, comments | Click-through rate (CTR) |
Impressions | Return on Ad Spend (ROAS) |
Followers gained | Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) |
Website sessions | Conversion rate (CVR) |
Video views | Cost per Purchase (CPP) |
Email open rate | Revenue per Email (RPE) |
Brands like Glossier, Athletic Greens, and Hydrant now measure campaigns based on impact, not applause.
Realignment in Marketing Teams
This mindset shift isn’t just about data. It’s changing how teams are structured, how creative is briefed, and how success is defined. Marketers are:
Collaborating closely with growth and analytics teams
Using blended metrics across paid + organic
Running A/B tests tied to sales, not just engagement
Expect 2025 to be the year when even branding and creative teams start reporting against performance benchmarks, not just storytelling wins.
Closing Thoughts
Vanity metrics once ruled dashboards because they were easy to understand and quick to spike. But in 2025, performance brands are chasing clarity, not claps.
If a number doesn’t lead to better targeting, lower CAC, or stronger LTV, it doesn’t deserve your attention.
Comments